Skip to main content
Israel News Pulse

Politics

Walid Taha's Deputy Speaker Nomination Is a Disgrace for Israeli Democracy

An empty presiding chair with microphones and an Israeli flag in a parliament chamber.

Replacing Netanyahu cannot justify promoting a lawmaker whose defense of jailed terrorists was reported in 2021 and who refused, in a separate interview that year, to call Hamas a terrorist organization. Eisenkot will own the choices his bloc makes.

Ra'am MK Walid Taha is being advanced toward the deputy speaker's chair in the Knesset. A politician whose record should count against such a promotion is instead being offered greater parliamentary authority as Gadi Eisenkot's bloc works to replace Benjamin Netanyahu.

On November 16, the Arrangements Committee voted 13 to 8 to recommend nine temporary deputy speakers, including Taha. The committee recommendation requires approval by the plenum. The political decision to advance him, however, has already been made.

It is a shameful choice. The desire to remove Netanyahu does not excuse it.

Listen to What He Says

In the accompanying clip's English subtitles, Taha describes those in prison as "prisoners of freedom, conscience and ideology." He says they are paying with years of their lives for "our just Palestinian cause."

Walid Taha's remarks, with English subtitles

HaKol HaYehudi's April 2021 account described those Taha was defending as terrorists held in Israeli prisons, including people who had murdered Jews or carried out other attacks. The longer translated interview concerned Mansour Abbas's use of the word terrorists during an exchange with Amit Segal. Taha was defending Abbas and rejecting that description.

The language matters. He presents imprisonment as a sacrifice for a just national struggle, without identifying individual cases or distinguishing between the acts for which they were held. That sweeping defense is precisely what makes the passage troubling.

Anyone supporting his promotion should have to confront those words. The public should not be expected to forget them because a parliamentary majority is being assembled.

The Answer He Would Not Give on Hamas

There is also a direct exchange about Hamas. In a March 25, 2021 interview on Kan's Reshet Bet, Taha was asked whether he regarded Hamas as a terrorist organization. Israel Hayom's report of the interview records his refusal to answer directly and his explanation that he and the interviewer used different terminology.

Both interviews predate October 7. They remain part of the record on which his suitability for this office should be judged. His backers should demand a clear current position before giving him authority.

A politician seeking a leadership role in Israel's parliament should be able to identify Hamas as a terrorist organization without retreating into a discussion about terminology. That is a basic standard. Parliamentary bargaining should not lower it.

The People Giving Him Power

The committee advancing Taha's nomination is chaired by Roy Folkman of Eisenkot's Yashar party. Eisenkot selected Matan Kahana as his bloc's candidate for Knesset speaker, within a broader agreement over parliamentary positions, Ynet reported.

This places the nomination inside the political effort Eisenkot is leading. He bears responsibility for the judgment his bloc exercises as it seeks control of the Knesset and a path to government.

Kahana has defended Arab parliamentary representation and rejected demands to exclude Arab party representatives from the deputy posts. Equal representation is a legitimate principle. It also leaves Taha's individual record fully open to scrutiny.

His backers risk becoming useful idiots in the pursuit of parliamentary control, lending respectability to a record they should be challenging. The ambition to replace Netanyahu supplies no answer to the words in this video.

Eisenkot Will Own This Choice

A deputy speaker can preside over plenary proceedings and exercise powers delegated by the speaker. The office carries authority over the workings of Israel's elected parliament. Choosing who receives it is a statement about the standards the Knesset intends to uphold.

Taha should be denied that promotion. If lawful grounds for deportation can be established, that option should be pursued through the legal process. The video alone does not establish those grounds; it does provide a reason to reject the political judgment behind his nomination.

A democracy should be able to defend itself while applying the same standards to every elected representative. Refusing to reward this record is a reasonable place to begin.

Advancing Taha toward the deputy speaker's chair is a low point for Israeli democracy. If Eisenkot stands behind the move, he will be remembered for the people he helped empower as well as the prime minister he sought to replace.

Eisenkot, this will be part of your legacy.

Contact Israel News Pulse

Tips, corrections and questions. We read everything and reply when we can.

We use your details only to answer you.

Prefer X? Message @israelnewspulse (opens in a new tab)

Contact

Advertise on Israel News Pulse

Reach readers in nine languages, on every page of the site.

Message us on WhatsApp (opens in a new tab)

Display settings

Text size100%

These settings are saved in this browser only. Read our accessibility statement.